CySEC Advanced · Chapter 13 · Topic 6 of 7

What must issuers do so that shareholders and bondholders can exercise their rights?

Equal treatment of shareholders and bondholders, the duties common to share and debt issuers, the notices each must publish, where debt holders' meetings may be held, the conditions for electronic communication, and the fine for breaches.

By the ExamPass CY editorial teamLast reviewed 7 min read

Short answer

Share issuers treat shareholders of the same class equally, and debt issuers all holders ranking pari passu. Both make the necessary facilities and information available in Cyprus, protect data integrity and security, never block proxy voting, provide proxy forms and designate a financial institution as agent for holders' financial rights. Shareholders get meeting, dividend and new-share notices; bondholders get meeting, interest, conversion and repayment notices. Electronic communication needs a general-meeting decision and a written request for consent, with silence counting as consent. Breaches cost up to €85,000, or €170,000 if repeated.

Communication with holders at a glance

Equal treatmentShareholders of the same class; holders of debt of equal rank (pari passu), for every right attached
Common dutiesFacilities and information available in Cyprus; integrity and security of data; no obstruction of proxy voting
Meeting information (shares)Place, time and agenda; total shares and voting rights; shareholders' right to take part
Proxy formSent with the meeting notice, on paper or electronically; on request where a meeting is called by public announcement
Financial-institution agentDesignated by share and debt issuers alike, so that holders can exercise their financial rights
Share-only noticesAllocation and payment of dividends; new share issues and how new shares are allotted, subscribed, cancelled or converted
Debt-only noticesMeetings; interest; conversion, exchange, subscription or cancellation rights; repayment; the right to take part
Debt meeting venueAny Member State with the facilities, if only holders of units of at least €100,000 are invited (€50,000 for debt admitted before 31 December 2010)
Electronic meansGeneral-meeting decision; residence-neutral; identification arrangements; written request, silence deemed consent; equal cost-sharing; paper on request
SanctionUp to €85,000; up to €170,000 on repetition, depending on gravity

Source: Law 190(I)/2007, sections 25, 26 and 27; Directive 2004/109/EC, Articles 17 and 18.

In the exam

The exam is written from the exam material, which predates the changes below. Expect its answer. If that answer is not among the options and the current rule is, choose the current rule.

  • Financial-institution agent

    Exam material: A share issuer designates a financial institution as agent, and publishes dividend and new-share notices, when it calls meetings by announcement without notice to each shareholder.

    Current law (since 2007 (Law 190(I)/2007, section 25(3))): Every share issuer designates such an agent and publishes those notices; the announcement case only means that proxy forms go to each shareholder on request.

  • Consent to electronic notices

    Exam material: Shareholders and debt holders must give written consent, though silence is presumed to be consent. For debt holders, no general-meeting decision is mentioned.

    Current law (since 2007 (Law 190(I)/2007, sections 25 and 26)): The general meeting decides, for shares and debt alike. Holders are asked in writing to consent, and silence for a reasonable period counts as consent.

What do share and debt issuers owe all their holders?

These rules make sure investors can actually exercise the rights attached to their securities. A share issuer must treat equally all shareholders of the same class. The exam material, like the Directive, speaks of shareholders in the same position; the Cyprus text has said 'of the same class' since 2007. A debt issuer must treat equally all holders of debt securities that rank pari passu, in respect of every right attached to those securities.

Both kinds of issuer must make available in Cyprus all the facilities and information that holders need to exercise their rights, keep data intact and secure, and not prevent holders from exercising their rights through a proxy, subject to the company law of the place where the issuer is incorporated. Both must also make a proxy form available, on paper or where applicable electronically, to every person entitled to vote, with the meeting notice; where a meeting is called by public announcement rather than by notice to each holder, the form goes to each holder who asks for it. And both must designate a financial institution as their agent, through which holders can exercise their financial rights.

Terms used in this note

Pari passu
Ranking equally, with no holder of the same debt having priority over another.
Proxy
A person authorised to vote on a holder's behalf at a meeting.
Financial-institution agent
The financial institution an issuer designates, through which holders exercise their financial rights.
Deemed consent
Consent to electronic communication treated as given when a holder, asked in writing, does not object within a reasonable period.

What must share issuers and debt issuers each publish?

A share issuer must tell shareholders where and when meetings will be held and what is on the agenda, how many shares and voting rights there are in total, and that they have the right to take part. It must also publish notices or circulars on the allocation and payment of dividends and on new share issues, including how new shares are allotted, subscribed, cancelled or converted. The exam material presents the financial-institution agent and the dividend and new-share notices as duties that arise when a meeting is called by announcement without notice to each shareholder. Since 2007 the Law has made them general duties of every share issuer; the announcement case only changes how proxy forms are provided.

A debt issuer publishes notices or circulars on where and when holders' meetings take place and their agenda, on interest payments and any exercise of conversion, exchange, subscription or cancellation rights, on repayment, and on holders' right to take part. Dividend notices are for share issuers only. If only holders of debt with a denomination of at least €100,000 a unit, or the equivalent, are invited, the issuer may hold the meeting in any Member State, provided all the facilities and information holders need are available there; for debt admitted to an EU regulated market before 31 December 2010 the figure is €50,000 while the debt is outstanding.

When may issuers communicate electronically?

Information may be sent electronically only if a general meeting has decided so and at least four conditions are met: the use of electronic means does not depend on where the holder, or a proxy, is based or resident; identification arrangements make sure holders are actually informed; holders are asked in writing to agree, and those who do not object within a reasonable period are treated as consenting; and any sharing of the costs respects equal treatment. A holder may later ask at any time to receive information in writing. The same conditions apply to debt issuers whose home Member State is Cyprus or which chose Cyprus as the meeting venue.

The exam material says written consent must be obtained from shareholders, and that debt holders must give written consent, although for both it also treats silence as consent. Since 2007 the Law has required only a written request for consent, and silence for a reasonable period counts as consent; a signed consent is not needed. For debt holders the exam material also leaves out the general-meeting decision, which the Law requires in both cases.

Breaching any of these communication duties exposes an issuer to a CySEC fine of up to €85,000, or up to €170,000 for a repeated breach, depending on gravity. That is far below the scale for the core disclosure duties.

How to think about it

Start from what every issuer owes every holder: equal treatment, facilities and information in Cyprus, secure data, free use of proxies, a proxy form and a financial-institution agent. Then add what depends on the security: dividend and new-share notices for shares; interest, conversion and repayment notices for debt, and freedom to meet in another Member State for high-denomination debt. For electronic communication, think: the meeting decides, holders are asked, silence agrees. The fine scale is the low one.

Common mistakes

  1. Tying the financial-institution agent to announcements. Every share and debt issuer designates one; an announcement only means proxy forms go out on request.

  2. Requiring signed consent for electronic notices. Holders are asked in writing, and silence for a reasonable period counts as consent, after a general-meeting decision.

  3. Giving bondholders dividend notices. Dividend and new-share notices are for shareholders; bondholders get interest, conversion and repayment notices.

  4. Moving any bondholder meeting abroad. Only when solely holders of units of at least €100,000 are invited (€50,000 for debt admitted before 31 December 2010).

  5. Using the heavy fine scale. Communication breaches carry €85,000, or €170,000 if repeated.

Practise this topic

Test what you just read

The Chapter 13 pack has 100 exam-style questions, 20 of them on this topic. Every question has a hint before you answer and a full explanation after.

Try the free demo

Or revise the numbers first with 18 free Chapter 13 flashcards →

Last reviewed on by the ExamPass CY editorial team against the law in force on that date. Study notes help you prepare for the CySEC exams; they are not legal advice. ExamPass CY is not affiliated with CySEC.

How we write study notesReport an error